HMRC has lost another important employment status case, this time involving football referees working for Professional Game Match Officials Ltd (PGMOL).
The tribunal ruled that the referees should not be treated as employees for tax purposes, rejecting HMRC’s argument that PAYE tax and National Insurance should have been applied to their match fees.
While the case centres around football referees, the decision carries an important message for businesses using contractors, freelancers and flexible workers across many industries.
What Was the Case About?
The case involved referees operating within the National Group who officiated matches in the English Football League.
HMRC argued that the referees were effectively employees because of the level of oversight and structure involved in their work. As a result, HMRC believed PAYE and National Insurance should have been deducted from payments made to them.
However, the tribunal disagreed.
The judges concluded that:
• The referees had insufficient control placed upon them to create an employment relationship
• There was no obligation for PGMOL to offer work
• There was no obligation for referees to accept work
Taken together, these points suggested the referees were operating more like independent contractors than employees.
Why Employment Status Matters
Employment status is one of the most important areas of tax compliance for businesses.
Whether someone is classified as an employee, worker, or self-employed
directly affects:
• PAYE responsibilities
• National Insurance contributions
• Holiday pay and employment rights
• Pension obligations
• IR35 compliance
Getting it wrong can lead to significant tax liabilities, interest and penalties.
Another Reminder That Employment Status Is Complex
This latest decision highlights something many businesses already know, employment status is rarely straightforward.
HMRC continues to challenge arrangements where individuals work flexibly or on an assignment-by-assignment basis. However, tribunals repeatedly show that employment status depends on the full reality of the relationship, not simply how closely someone is monitored or managed.
Three factors remain especially important:
1. Control
How much control does the business have over how, when and where the work is carried out?
2. Mutuality of Obligation
Is the business required to provide work, and is the individual required to accept it?
3. The Overall Working Relationship
What does the relationship look like in practice, not just on paper?
Even detailed operational oversight does not automatically create employment status if the wider relationship points towards self-employment.
What Businesses Should Take From This
If your business works with freelancers, subcontractors or consultants, this case is a useful reminder to regularly review your arrangements.
Do not rely solely on contracts
A contract can help support your position, but HMRC and tribunals will always look at what happens in reality.
Review working practices
Ask yourself:
• Can the individual refuse work?
• Are they working project by project?
• Do they control how the work is completed?
• Are they integrated into the business like an employee?
Keep records up to date
Documenting the nature of the relationship can help support your position if HMRC ever asks questions.
Why IR35 Still Matters
Although this case was not specifically an off-payroll working case under the private sector IR35 rules, the principles are closely linked.
Businesses engaging contractors through limited companies still need to carefully assess employment status. HMRC remains highly active in this area and continues to investigate businesses it believes may have incorrectly classified workers.
A status review today could prevent costly disputes later.
The Bigger Picture
This decision is another example of the challenges HMRC faces in proving employment status where work is flexible, irregular or assignment-based.
For businesses, it reinforces the importance of looking beyond job titles and written agreements. The practical day-to-day reality of the relationship remains central to determining tax status.
Need Help Reviewing Contractor or IR35 Arrangements?
Employment status rules can be difficult to navigate, especially as working patterns continue to evolve.
We support businesses across Stevenage and Hertfordshire with practical guidance on contractor arrangements, employment status and IR35 compliance. If you would like help reviewing your current setup or understanding your responsibilities, get in touch and we will guide you step by step.
A proactive review now can help avoid expensive problems later.
Share this post: